The Mermaid & The Alligator


729 Truman Avenue


Use Promo Code FINE for a 10% Discount

Mention KWFINEST for the lowest rate.


The Mermaid & The Alligator has often been voted Best B&B on the island.  This is really the quintessential environment that you expect when you stay at a classic bed and breakfast.  From the beautifully decorated rooms to the lush grounds, the Mermaid & The Alligator has all of the comforts of home including freshly made breakfast by the pool each and every morning!

With only nine rooms, this place fills up fast so be sure to book well in advance especially around the holidays.

Amber, Key West!

Key West's Finest

Inn Amenities

  • Heated Swim Spa
  • Complimentary breakfast served poolside.
  • Complimentary Wine served nightly
  • Complimentary bottle water and soda selection
  • Afternoon Lemonade and snacks
  • Espresso and Tea available on request
  • Amenities-toiletries basket
  • Concierge services, dinner reservations, tickets, tours and massages
  • Fax, & copy services
  • Complimentary Nationwide and Canada phone calls
  • Complementary 24-hour guest computer station
  • Complimentary onsite parking. (one standard size vehicle)
  • Bike rack
  • Pool and beach towels, sunscreen
  • Ice machine
  • Guest refrigerator

Guest Room Amenities:

  • Air conditioning and heat
  • Private tile baths with oversized showers. (3 with bathtubs)
  • Queen or king size Comfort Choice 2-sided luxury mattresses
  • 400 thread-count “Charisma” egyptian cotton sheets
  • Luxury Turkish cotton towels
  • Synthetic down duvet and pillows – alternative available
  • Gilchrist & Soames bath amenities
  • Plush bath robes
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi (Guest computer with printer in living room)
  • Table top, surge protected multi-port electrical outlets
  • Laptop computer lap desks
  • iPod docking station stereo system
  • CD/AM/FM/ Clock Radio
  • Sound therapy systems
  • Iron, ironing board, and hairdryer
  • Safes

The Mermaid & The Alligator